Review: Case Histories

Now that I finally have time for fun books again I thought I’d sort out the books I have here at my parents and put the ones I didn’t like up on bookmooch. It’s really weird that loving to read means reading anything to the extended family, but I hope someone will have more fun with these books than I had. Anyway, while I was sorting and dusting, I noticed Case Histories by Kate Atkinson on my shelf. I had no idea I owned this! I remember trying something by Atkinson at some point but I think I didn’t enjoy it that much. But then looking at my poor neglected copy,  I remembered Simon of Savidge Reads mentioning how much he loves Atkinson’s series, and so I decided to give it a try. I’m glad I did!

Case Histories is the first book in a series around private detective (and former police officer) Jackson Brodie, and is set in Cambridge. But the novel starts with three case histories: Three year old Olivia disappears from the tent in her garden one night, 18 year old Lauren is attacked by an unknown man in a yellow golfing sweater, and young mother Michelle looses control and kills her husband. These cases all take place at different times and seem to be unconnected. The only link between them is that Brodie is asked to investigate them by Olivia’s sisters, Lauren’s father, and Michelle’s sister wanting to find her niece. Brodie is not a very happy man, he is divorced from his wife and is haunted by a personal tragedy, which is a fourth case history. His private eye business, too, is going slow, most of his cases are provided by old eccentric Binky Rain, who asks Jackson to find some of her many cats. When these three cases are dropped in his lap, he is not very optimistic about solving them, however, he is a nice guy and takes a real interest in those family members left behind. There are the Land sisters, Amelia and Julia, who find Blue Mouse, Olivia’s toy, the one she disappeard with. There’s Lauren’s fathers Theo, to whom she was and still is the world, and Michelle’s sister who wants to find her niece.

Of the three opening chapters, the case histories, I was most invested in Olivia Land’s. Atkinson introduces the reader to a dysfunctional family, the distant father, the exhausted mother, neither of whom appears to be very interested in the children. The sisters in turn are all slightly weird but all very much their own person, and it is interesting to find out what has become of them thirty years later. Atkinson suceeds in creating characters that are likable but odd, tragic but unintentionally funny. There are not too few characters but all of them come to life. Perhaps this is part of the reason why critics refer to Case Histories as literary crime. This book is one that can be enjoyed by crime- and non-crime readers alike. Although it has a detective and cases of missing persons, the focus is as much on the tragedy of losing someone close and dealing with how to move on from that, as it is on the mystery of the cases. You want to find out what happened, but  that is not the central question of this book.

Case Histories is probably one of those books that has people gushing about how it transcends the genre and combines the best of genres etc. This is somewhat insulting to the ‘conventional’ genres, but I suppose I get their meaning. Even if literary crime sounds somewhat pretentious, I think I like it. I hope that means my reading horizons are expanding :)

Other thoughts:

Teresa at Shelf Love

Have you reviewed this book? Let me know and I’ll add a link!

Teaser Tuesday

My teaser this week comes from a pastiche of Golden Age detective fiction set in 1946 in England. A Mysterious Affair of Style is an homage to Agatha Christie’s mysteries in particular and both emulates and makes fun of the conventions of the classic whodunit.

ANY_CHARACTERS_HERE

“In other words, what generates the tension you describe is the reader’s fear not that the detective will fail- he knows that’ never going to happen- but that the author will fail.’”

“It’s what you call clever-clever, which sounds twice as clever as clever itself but is actually only half.”

(Gilbert Adair: A Mysterious Affair of Style. 11 & 15)

ANY_CHARACTERS_HERE
ANY_CHARACTERS_HERE
ANY_CHARACTERS_HERE
ANY_CHARACTERS_HERE
ANY_CHARACTERS_HERE

Teaser Tuesday is hosted by Should Be Reading and this is how it works:

  • Grab your current read
  • Open to a random page
  • Share two (2) “teaser” sentences from somewhere on that page
  • BE CAREFUL NOT TO INCLUDE SPOILERS! (make sure that what you share doesn’t give too much away! You don’t want to ruin the book for others!)
  • Share the title & author, too, so that other TT participants can add the book to their TBR Lists if they like your teasers!

Mailbox Monday

“Mailbox Monday is the gathering place for readers to share the books that came into their house last week. Warning: Mailbox Monday can lead to envy, toppling TBR piles and humongous wish lists.” Mailbox Monday is hosted by Chick Loves Lit this month.

While I was buried in term papers and couldn’t read much for fun, it was nice to see a small pile of books forming in my room! I have no idea how to take all these books back with me in October though :)

Women, Autobiography, Theory- A Reader (Smith and Watson)

Starting with the nerdy book :) I needed that for a paper, but I still love having had such agreat excuse to buy a book. If you’re interested in women life writing, definitely read this one!

The Moving Toyshop (Edmund Crispin)

This one’s from bookmooch. Obviously there’s got to be detective fiction in a book pile of mine somewhere. This one is set in the 30s and supposed to be charming. Has anyone read Crispin’s works?

After the Armistice Ball (Catriona McPherson)

On with the detective fiction. This one is the first book in a series, set in Scotland in the 20s and starring amateur sleuth Dandy Gilver. My mom got me this, and I enjoyed it a lot. Will post my review sometime this week.

Ein Glas voll Segen/ A Glass of Blessings (Barbara Pym)

Another mooch. I loved Pym’s Excellent Women and can’t wait to read more by her.

The Book of Lost Things (John Connolly)

And another mooch. I loved Connolly’s The Gates and have heard lots of good things about this one.

Attack (Yasmina Khadra)

I won this one at Amy‘s giveaway, together with Nemesis by Phillip Roth. Thank you, Amy!

Mr. Rosenblum’s List (Natasha Solomons)

A lovely book, you can find my review here. And make sure to enter my giveaway!

The Lifted Veil (George Eliot)

Mooched. Thought I’d try a smaller Eliot, and I don’t think one can go wrong with Virago classics.

Agatha Raisin and the Viscious Vet (M.C. Beaton)

Also mooched. I love the Agatha Raisin series for comfort reading. I’m reading this now, since it’s so grey and rainy outside, perfect weather to spend on the couch with a cosy crime.

Pygmy (Chuck Palahniuk)

I love a good satire, especially if it’s dark and sinister. I don’t either completely love or hate Palahniuk’s works, so it’s always a gamble, but I really want to like this one.

Have you read any of these books? And what books arrived in your home?

Make sure to pop by Aisle B and Mrs Q: Book Addict for their Mailbox Monday posts!

Review: Mr. Rosenblum’s List + Giveaway

Hey y’all, I’m back from my paper-induced hiatus, and I thought I’d celebrate by doing a giveaway of Mr. Rosenblum’s List. All you have to do to win my (used, that is crinkly spine) paperback copy of Mr. Rosenblum’s List is

1.) leave a comment that you’d like to enter the giveaway,

2.) let me know your email address and

3.) tell me what you think should go on the list of the aspiring Englishman.

You have till midnight September 11 to enter the giveaway, and I’ll announce the winner on September 13. This giveaway is open worldwide!

Jack Rosenblum is five foot three and a half inches of sheer tenacity. Through study and application he intends to become a Very English Gentleman. Jack is compiling a list, a comprehensive guide to the manners, customs and habits of this country. He knows that marmalade must be bought from Fortnum & Mason, he’s memorised the entire British monarchy back to 913 A.D and the highlight of his day is the BBC weather forecast. And he never speaks German, apart from the occasional curse. From the moment he disembarked at Harwich in 1937 he understood that assimilation was the key. But the war’s been over for eight years and despite his best efforts, his bid to blend in remains fraught with unexpected hurdles. Including his wife. Sadie finds his obsession baffling. She doesn’t want to forget who they are or where they come from. She’d rather bake cakes to remember the people they left behind than worry about how to play bridge. But Jack is convinced they can find a place to call home. In a final attempt to complete his list, he leads a reluctant Sadie into the English countryside. Here, in a land of woolly pigs, bluebells and jitterbug cider, they embark on an impossible task… (amazon)

I’ve never really been on the best of terms with blurbs, but I think the ones on this book have cured me from believing them at all. The Times calls Mr. Rosenblum’s List “hilarious”, and another paper refers to it as “very funny”. It’s an enjoyable book, but it’s still quite sad. And how can a story about exile really be hilarious, except maybe for those who observe (and make fun of) any attempts at integration.

Jack Rosenblum, his wife Sadie and their daughter emigrate from Germany in 1937, and the moment they arrive in England, Jack is handed a list with advice for Jewish refugees. This guidance tells Jack that speaking halting English is much better than speaking German, that he should not express any political views or join an organisation, that he should immediately imitate the English way of dressing (“bland is best”), their manners and customs. In other words, completely cast of his German Jewish origins. Jack (and his name is the first thing to change) decides that assimilation is the key to his family’s happiness and meticulously works his way down the list. However, assimilation proves much more difficult than he imagined, and Jack notes down more items. He becomes obsessed with the list and his dream of becoming an English gentleman. In his tenaciously optimistic way, Jack believes that all failure at assimilation is his fault, and that by observing the English closely, he will become English. Of course, being five foot three and a half inches, having a schnoz and a German accent, blending in is nearly impossible. Again and again, Jack comes up against the English bias towards foreigners (and in those days especially Krauts), their class system and anti-semitism. That Jack continues to work hard at becoming English in the face of this prejudice is all the more painful and tragic because he remains so optimistic.

While Jack attempts complete assimilation, his wife Sadie clings to her own culture. Leaving Germany, the Rosenblums had to leave behind Sadie’s parents and her brother to die. While Jack steadfastly refuses to look back, Sadie cannot let go of her past. She tries to keep Jewish traditions alive, especially by baking from her mother’s cooking book. With those two very different attitudes toward assimilation, Jack and Sadie drift apart. Sadie is horrified that Jack rejects his origins, and Jack is ashamed of his German Jewish wife and tries to force her to assimilate. For example, he only speaks English, even with his wife. And when Jack is refused membership in any of the great English golfclubs, he takes his wife out of London and away to the country, without asking her. In Dorset, the ‘Rose-in-blooms’ have to assimilate to country life, woolly pigs, and jitterbug cider. And by building his own golf course, Jack makes a final attempt at becoming completely English.

Natasha Solomon’s has written a lovely book that combines exile literature with the genre of eccentric but warm-hearted English country life. This is why this novel is both sad and cosy, a comfort read but with serious underlying issues, which you can ponder over if you’re in the mood. I really enjoyed Mr. Rosenblum’s List, even though I find exile, diaspora and assimilation very painful to read. But Solomon’s tone makes you think that just maybe things are going to work out for the Rosenblums. And her German didn’t even make me wince! :)

So if you’d like a copy of Mr. Rosenblum’s List, remember to enter the giveaway!

Have you reviewed this book? Let me know and I’ll add a link!

Update

via

Surprise, I’m still alive (somewhat)! I’m sorry I just disappeared without a word and haven’t been reading and commenting on your posts. But between going home for the semester break and writing  term papers, I haven’t been able to concentrate on much else. And I haven’t been reading much fiction either :(

I had to take a break from reading The End of Mr. Y, I just can’t take the frequent references to Derrida et al when I’m writing papers (or in general ;) ). So now I’m in the middle of After the Armistice Ball by Catriona McPherson, a cosy crime which is set in Scotland after WWI, and which my mom got me. I finished Mr. Rosenblum’s List last week and I enjoyed it, but I have no idea why two blurbs said it was hilarious and funny, because this is one of the saddest books I’ve ever read. Did I miss something?

Not much else going on with me, I’m reading and writing all day and then somehow seem to spend most of my evenings at the movies. Somehow, the more people tell me how great Inception is, the less I find I like it, which is weird because I had a nice enough evening watching it (not that it was awe-inspiring or anything).

I’ll definitely be back to blogging and lots of fun reading in September but if I don’t get around to visiting your blogs until then, please don’t take it personally!

Hope you’re all having a great week! :)

  • Currently reading:

  • Just finished:

  • TBR

    No data found
    Book recommendations, book reviews, quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 44 other followers