Review: Ten Little Herrings
Posted by Bina on October 10, 2011

Ten Little Herrings by L. C. Tyler is the second book in a series of homage-spoof-parody to the classic mystery starring crime-writer Ethelred Tressider and his literary agent Elsie Thirkettle. I had the first book, The Herring Seller’s Apprentice out from the library a while ago but didn’t get around to reading it. On my last library visit I was really in the mood for cosy and lighthearted crime but found only the second instalment. Oh well, I didn’t want to wait and just started reading this one. And I’m glad I did because it was lots of fun!
Ten Little Herrings takes on the classic of crime fiction, the country house murder. The country house in question is a hotel in France and just why and how Ethelred and Elsie come to be there, I’ll let you find out for yourselves.
Apart from Elsie and Ethelred, most other guests are part of a convention of stamp collectors. They are a much more deadly bunch then you’d first assume (or possibly not, if you’ve read The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie) and it doesn’t take long before they start murdering each other. While Ethelred ponders, Elsie pounces, and the result is just hilarious. What I really enjoyed was the alternating point of view, Ethelred provides a bit of background information and Elsie does most of the chasing. The sleuthing is noticeably done by amateurs, but always with perfect grammar!
I tend to side automatically with characters (and people) who love chocolate and Elsie was no exception. This gets her into all sorts of trouble but I thought she had a perfectly good reason
Also, gotta love her publishing ethics, even if I do feel a bit sorry for Ethelred:
The Elsie Thirkettle Agency quickly attracted a number of promising young authors of high literary merit, but I managed to dump most of them. It’s a question of quality, not quantity, you see. The agricultural revolution was all about getting two crops a year out of a field that previously gave you one. It’s much the same with books. The royalties on a book that has taken five years to produce are usually much the same as on one written in six months. I can double-, sometimes treble-, crop my authors.
If the weather in your part of the world is anything like it is here at the moment – cold, wet, very windy- then put the kettle on and curl up with Elsie and Ethelred!
Have you reviewed this book? Let me know and I’ll add a link!
Like this:
This entry was posted on October 10, 2011 at 23:04 and is filed under Author, Book, British, Review. Tagged: Elsie and Ethelred, L. C. Tyler, Mystery, mystery homage, Ten Little Herrings. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.




















winstonsdad said
I ve not but like title sort homage to christie ,there seems a lot of cosy mysteries about these days ,all the best stu
Bina said
There’s definitely no shortage of cosy crime on my blog
It’s a great book and homage.
Vishy said
Nice review, Bina! I love that cover
Chocolate-loving characters are really nice! I liked that passage that you have quoted from the book. It really made me think.
Bina said
Love the cover as well. And it’s hilarious the trouble Elsie gets into just because she needs chocolate
Louise said
I’m just starting to get round to cosy mysteries – downloaded my first Agatha Raisin the other day, looks like I might add this to the list. Nice review.
Bina said
Thanks for stopping by, Louise. Then you have still lots of amazing cosies to discover! Agatha Raisin is lots of fun, enjoy
Nymeth said
How is it possible that I hadn’t heard of this series before? I want it right now! And like Vishy I just love the cover
Bina said
Heh, it’s such fun reading, like the cover suggests. Hope you’ll like the series. I need to get my hands on the first book
jessicabookworm said
Unsurprisingly I’ve never heard of this series either! I must admit the weather is getting colder here and I’m really getting into the mood for some cosy crime
Bina said
It’s a perfect cosy for a cold, wet evening. Hope you’ll have fun with those two sleuths
Mirjam said
This book looks like fun and I would love to read about a character who gets into a lot of trouble or the sake of eating chocolate.
Bina said
That does rather make a instantly likeable!
I think you’d enjoy this series, it’s super fun, but still a great mystery.
Jennifer said
Thanks for the excellent suggestion. My library had the first two available, and I plowed through them in a couple of days. I’ve got to put the next one on hold, and should be able to read it next weekend. The American covers are not as good as the original British covers. Very cartoony and colorful. Good, but not at all suggestive of the characters.
And on another favorite, I read the Blandings portion of Blandings Castle, a selection of short stories. The first six, I think, are all Blandings. In these, the Hon. Freddie finds his Aggie and gets married, and even more momentously, the Empress of Blandings makes her debut. I’m slowly making my way through the series, and have the audio book for Summer Lightning for the next installment.
Bina said
So happy they were a success with you, Jennifer
The UK vs US cover thing can really be hit and miss, but I’m glad that didn’t scare you off reading this series.
Aww, you make me want to rush through to the next instalment in the Blandings Castle series. I’ve only gotten till Leave it to Psmith, but all sorts of Wodehouse madness is going on already!
The birthday loot « If you can read this said
[...] in the Library by L.C. Tyler is the third Elsie and Ethelred book. Remember how much fun I had reading the last instalment? Well, my friend gave me got me this one so that I wouldn’t miss out on the duo vs the [...]
Penny said
Trying to catch up on my favourite bloggers! I know this is an old-ish post, but I wanted to let you know that I’ve just downloaded the first book in the series onto my Kindle! I love the cover you’ve shown, but the quick download won!
Have you read the James Anderson books? Also very funny spoofs. Sadly, he died after writing just three. I recommend them highly!
Bina said
Aww, thanks Penny! I’m excited that you got the first Herring book, hope you’ll enjoy it! You can always get the actual books later when you’re a fan and want to display your good taste on your shelf
I’ve read the first Anderson book and absolutely loved it, so funny! I haven’t read the other two yet, they are kind of my stache for when I’m feeling in need of a great pick-me up. Love those covers, too.
Penny said
I had kept the last one for this purpose, but last Christmas I had a very bad flu and, once I was able to read, I re-read the first two and enjoyed them all over again and then read the third. Perfect reading for when you’re miserable!
Bina said
They really make for perfect reading when you’re ill! Maybe now you’ve got the Herring series for that