Mini reviews: Oldies, Classics and Cozies

In an attempt to catch up on my reviews I’ve decided to post some mini reviews and thus spare you my longer rambling 🙂

Major Pettigrew’s Last Stand by Helen Simonson was very present on blogs and online magazines and the story of the friendship of a retired major and a Pakistani shopkeeper in a British village sounded wonderful, so I was very happy to find a copy at the library here. Both Major Pettigrew and Mrs. Ali are widowed and they bond over their shared love of literature. The villagers however continue to view her as a stranger and don’t want Pettigrew, a quintessential English gentleman, to get mixed up with “her sort”. However, Mrs Ali is actually from Cambridge, while the major was born in Lahore. The tentative friendship that blossoms into more, the setting of rural England and the quiet dignity of the main characters are wonderful and made for a charming read. A couple of aspects kept this from being a perfect read for me. Both Mrs. Ali and major Pettigrew have family members who got on my nerve a lot. Pettigrew’s son is selfish, greedy and apparently a typical representative of the yup. I was tempted to skip the passages where he opened his mouth. Except for very few moments he remains an unlikable cardboard character. Then there is Mrs. Ali’s nephew who is caught between religion, tradition and love. His story turns into a melodrama with action scenes that seem out-of-place. I also thought that the melodrama around Mrs. Ali’s family rather inforced the image of the uncivilized “foreigner”, which is a shame as the rest of the novel is very well-written and gives us conflicted but interesting characters. It’s not perfect but I would still recommend giving it a try, best read it on a rainy Sunday with a cup of tea.

In a German Pension was my first go at Katharine Mansfield’s works. It’s a short story collection which focuses on the experiences of a young English woman in a German pension. She observes the behaviour of the other residents, remaining mostly distant and ironic in her attitude towards them. In fact, the narrator is downright caustic and patronizing and seems to really hate Germans. I think she had to spend too much time around the same people, all for the sake of benefiting from the spa (the tension between the two nations and the looming WWI probably didn’t help). But I very much enjoyed reading her views (and I assume Mansfield’s) about the role and treatment of women and how unprogressive the guests are in their views on separate spheres. The story about a woman in childbirth is a fine example of that.

Since this is a work which Mansfield herself described as immature (and I have to agree with regard to stereotypical notions), I’m looking forward to reading her other well-known collection The Garden Party. Is there a notable difference in style and attitude?

Forster’s Where Angels Fear to Tread is also my first attempt at reading one of his works though I’ve seen parts of the adaptation of Howard’s End, which I enjoyed a lot.

English widow Lilia Herrington travels to Italy where she falls in love with a young Italian. Her respectable family from her dead husband’s side are scandalized and attempt to stop Lilia before she brings more shame on them. However, when her brother-in-law arrives, he finds Lilia already married. Lilia settles into marriage in a small Italian town but her passion for the country and her new husband don not last when she realizes that he is lazy and adulterous and while she is completely cut off from social life. When Lilia dies in childbirth, her relatives are horrified at the thought of a scandal and  an English child being raised by its ill-mannered Italian father, and so try to get custody.

Forster’s depiction of the Herrington’s hypocrisy and their obsession with being proper and is wonderful to read, and I also loved the effect Italy and its beauty had on the British upper-class characters, how it awakens passion in them. While I enjoyed both the social commentary and the style, I didn’t love this book. But perhaps Forster’s other works are better or he’ll just have to grow on me, either way I want to try his other novels. A Room with a View and Howard’s End seem to be favorites, which one would you recommend I try next?

Have you reviewed any of these books? Let me know and I’ll add a link!

18 thoughts on “Mini reviews: Oldies, Classics and Cozies

  1. You could have also called these mini reviews “Cultures meet”. 🙂
    They all sound very interesting, especially In a German Pension, since I am always curious how the Germans are presented by non-German authors. Thanks for extending my tbr-list constantly. 🙂

    1. Heh, that’s a good title, too 😀 The Germans represented in Mansfield’s collection nare really idiotic and borish. Sorry for your tbr list ;)That happens to me too with every blog post I read.

  2. The first two books that you cover here really intrigue me. When Major Pettigrew first came out, I had a friend who said she thought it was exactly my kind of book, but I must have been in a funk because the beginning didn’t capture me. I do want to try it now, though! And I definitely want to read some Katherine Mansfield. I took out an audio collection of “women’s short stories” to listen to while I knit and the first story was one by her that I really enjoyed. This collection sounds so good, and like a really interesting premise.

    1. Hope you like Major Pettigrew this time around, maybe it’ll help with the cozy season starting 🙂 Listening to Mansfield while knitting sounds very cozy! 🙂

  3. Katharine Mansfield was one of the few primary influences on the man who changed my life, Horton Foote, screenplay writer of To Kill A Mockingbird and writer of many other beautiful plays.

    Mansfield is first rate: the real thing.

    1. I think I didn’t start with the best works by Mansfield and Forster, but now I won’t be disappointed like I probably would if I had started with the best ons 🙂 They are still interesting though.

  4. I am waiting to read Major Pettigrew! As you said it’s perfect as a light read, for a rainy day. For Forster, I would recommend A Passage to India. I found Room With a View a bit boring, but that’s just me. On the other hand, this was part of my English Masters syllabus and I enjoyed A Passage to India.

    On another note, I read my first Agatha Christie! Murder on the Links is what I read, recommended by Thoughts 🙂 I loved it! Will post a mini-review soon 🙂

    1. I’ll try both A Room with a View and Passage to India then 🙂 Hope you’ll enjoy Major Pettigrew!

      So glad you’re now a Christie fan! Looking forward to your review of it 🙂 And I enjoyed Murder on the Links a lot as well.

  5. Lovely mini-reviews, Bina! ‘Major Pettigrew’s Last Stand’ looks like an interesting book to me. I will add it to my wishlist. I love the cover of the Katherine Mansfield collection that you read. I have read her story ‘A Garden Party’ a few times and it is one of my favourite short stories. ‘Where Angels Fear to Tread’ is an interesting title.

    1. Thanks, Vishy! I’ll have to read Garden Party soon, it sounds really good 🙂 Hope you enjoy Majpr Pettigrew and the Forster book!

  6. I need to do some mini reviews to catch up too, I’m so behind! September was probably my worst blogging month all year.
    Where Angels Fear to Tread sounds fantastic! I’d love to read it now! I have a copy of A Room With A View at home but I haven’t read it yet.

    1. The number of still to be reviewed books can be frightening! 😀 Hope you’ll enjoy the Forster books, I want to read A Room with a View, too.

  7. WOW! 3 for 1 ! You making me feel bad! Love the mini review very quick and to the point. Try A Room With A View! That one since it is somewhat …romance… hee hee hee. My true nature lurks at the sign of love potential in plots.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s